Free Guide to Replacing Your Exterior Door Threshold

Understanding Door Thresholds and Why They Matter

A door threshold is the horizontal piece that sits at the bottom of your exterior doorframe, right where the door meets the outside. It's one of the most overlooked but important parts of your home's exterior. The threshold serves several critical functions: it creates a seal between your interior and the outdoor environment, helps water drain away from your home, provides a barrier against drafts and pests, and offers a finished appearance to your doorway.

Get Your Free Driver's License Transfer State Guide →

Most exterior thresholds are made from materials like aluminum, vinyl, wood, or composite materials. Aluminum thresholds are durable and low-maintenance but can conduct cold. Vinyl thresholds offer good insulation and are resistant to rot and insects. Wood thresholds look attractive but require regular maintenance and can rot over time if not properly sealed. Composite thresholds combine benefits of multiple materials and are becoming increasingly popular for exterior doors.

A damaged or deteriorating threshold causes real problems in your home. Water can seep into your foundation, leading to mold, mildew, and structural damage. Drafts increase your heating and cooling costs. Insects and rodents find entry points. The door may not close or open smoothly. Many homeowners notice a visible gap forming between the threshold and the door, water pooling on the threshold after rain, or the threshold cracking and splitting apart.

The good news is that replacing a threshold is a project most homeowners with basic tools can tackle. You don't need specialized equipment or professional training. The project typically takes between two and four hours, depending on how difficult the old threshold is to remove and the specific materials involved. Understanding the process helps you decide whether to DIY or hire a contractor, and either way, you'll know what work needs to happen.

Takeaway: Your door threshold protects your home from water intrusion, drafts, and pests. When thresholds fail, they create entry points for moisture and air leaks. Recognizing the signs of a failing threshold helps you address the problem before it causes more expensive damage.

Tools and Materials You'll Need

Before you start removing your old threshold, gather the right tools. Most of these are basic items that many homeowners already have in their garage or workshop. A reciprocating saw or oscillating multi-tool with a metal-cutting blade helps you cut through fasteners that may be stuck. A pry bar or flat crowbar lets you leverage the old threshold out without damaging the surrounding frame. A hammer helps drive the pry bar under the threshold. A utility knife scores caulk and sealant so the threshold comes out more easily. A handsaw or power saw cuts the new threshold to the correct length. Shims are small wedges used to level the new threshold perfectly.

Get Your Free Blister Care Information Guide →

A power drill with bits makes installation faster, though you can use a screwdriver by hand. Measuring tape and a level are essential—the new threshold must be perfectly level or water will pool on one side. A caulking gun applies sealant around the edges. Wear work gloves to protect your hands from sharp metal edges and splinters. Safety glasses protect your eyes when cutting or using power tools. Weatherproof caulk and sealant prevent water from getting behind the new threshold.

The threshold material itself is your largest purchase. Measure the width of your doorway from the inside edge of one side of the frame to the other. Most exterior doors are 36 inches wide, but measure yours. Some thresholds come in standard lengths and require cutting; others can be ordered to your specific measurement. When purchasing, buy a threshold slightly longer than your measurement so you can trim it to fit exactly. Many home improvement stores offer cutting services if you don't have the tools to do it yourself.

Consider purchasing additional supplies: exterior-grade weatherstripping tape if your new threshold doesn't come with it, fasteners (usually screws specifically designed for the threshold type you're installing), and extra caulk. Some thresholds require a base pan underneath to ensure proper water drainage—check whether your threshold needs this component before purchasing.

Takeaway: Threshold replacement requires basic hand tools and a few specialty items. Most homeowners already own the necessary tools. The main purchase is the threshold itself, which you should order or buy slightly larger than your doorway width to allow for custom fitting.

Removing Your Old Threshold Safely and Properly

Start by removing or opening your exterior door fully so it's out of the way. Look underneath and around the edges of your old threshold to find fasteners. Most thresholds are attached with screws driven from underneath or through the threshold into the frame below. Some older thresholds may be nailed. If you see screws, simply remove them with your drill or screwdriver. If the threshold is sealed with caulk, use your utility knife to cut through the sealant on all sides—top, bottom, and sides. Don't skip this step; failing to cut the caulk makes removal significantly harder and may damage the doorframe.

Free Guide to Wisconsin DMV Visits →

Once fasteners are removed and caulk is cut, place your pry bar under one end of the threshold. Apply steady pressure upward, moving along the threshold as sections begin to lift. Work gradually rather than forcing it—thresholds are sometimes glued in addition to being fastened, and patience prevents frame damage. If the threshold is stubborn, use your oscillating multi-tool to cut any remaining fasteners you may have missed. Some thresholds have a metal or plastic spine running underneath that extends into the frame—look for this and remove it carefully.

As the threshold comes free, set it aside carefully; some materials like aluminum have sharp edges. Inspect the space where the threshold was. Look for rot, water damage, or deterioration in the wood subfloor or frame. Soft, spongy wood or black staining indicates rot that needs treatment before installing the new threshold. Use a scraper or stiff brush to remove old caulk, sealant, and debris from the opening. The space must be clean and dry for the new threshold to seal properly.

If you discover rotted wood, you have two options. For minor rot affecting only a small area, use wood filler rated for exterior use, let it cure fully, then sand smooth. For extensive rot affecting the structural integrity of the frame, you may need to reinforce or replace that section of the frame—this is a good time to call a professional contractor. Check that the threshold opening is straight by using your level across the space in multiple directions. Thresholds must sit on a level surface or water will pool on the low side.

Takeaway: Remove fasteners first, then cut away all sealant before prying out the old threshold. Inspect the space for rot or damage, clean thoroughly, and verify the surface is level before proceeding to installation.

Installing Your New Threshold Step-by-Step

Position your new threshold in the opening and check the fit. If it's too long, mark the cut line and use your saw to trim it. Some thresholds have adjustable width pieces that slide—check your product instructions for this feature. Before fastening anything permanently, verify that the threshold is perfectly level using your level tool. Place shims under the threshold as needed, adding them gradually until the surface is perfectly level in all directions. This step is critical because even slight slopes cause water to pool.

Your Free Guide to Hernando County DMV Services →

With the threshold leveled, fasten it according to the manufacturer's instructions. Most modern thresholds use corrosion-resistant screws driven from underneath or through pre-drilled holes. Pre-drilling prevents cracking in composite or vinyl thresholds. Space fasteners approximately every 12 inches along the length. Don't over-tighten screws—they should be snug but not so tight that they crack the material or compress it unevenly. If your threshold came with weatherstripping tape, apply it to the underside or top surface as directed.

Once fastened, apply exterior-grade caulk or sealant around all edges of the threshold. This prevents water from getting behind it and running underneath to the subfloor. Apply caulk along where the threshold meets the frame on both sides, and along the front edge where it meets the floor. Smooth the caulk with a wet finger or caulk tool for a neat appearance and proper adhesion. Let the caulk cure for the time specified by the manufacturer—typically 24 hours—before exposing it to water.

Check that your door opens and closes smoothly over the new threshold. If it binds or catches, the threshold may be slightly too high. Modern thresholds are designed to be low-profile to prevent tripping